I have volunteered to temporarily help out my buddy Z a bit--so here I am to grade your post!
First--to your question: you generally just post the progress of the battle, focusing more on your character's actions. But you're entirely allowed to inflict damage on the other person's character, or take damage from them yourself--just don't control them too much to the point where you're doing things that would be out of character for them, or you're...say, breaking their unbreakable sword or something. It should make
sense. There should be a reason why you were able to maybe break their arm, or get in through their defenses, or evade their attack. You will
have to take some hits, realistically and logically. Don't feel forced to post long posts--short posts help the action move along quicker and frees you up from worrying about whether or not you controlled the other person too much.
Does all of that help? ^___^ Let me know if I should elaborate on anything more.
Now, to your evaluation:
Quote:
|
He could not even clench his hand; it was as if the stone had formed after his figure.
|
This sentence is a little awkward--and the bolded word "after" here is the reason. I'm not sure if you meant to put "around" instead, or if you meant that the stone had formed after he sank. If it's the latter, you should rephrase it to be more like:
Quote:
|
He could not even clench his hand; it was as if the stone had formed after he'd sunk.
|
The way you have it originally sounds like the stone formed after Carcaroth's figure/body formed...and he obviously didn't just materialize or something, so that's not right. If I'm missing some other meaning here, let me know. ^^;;
Quote:
|
However, through his entire life he had never used magic, and there was no doubt that he would need to do just that in order to get out his current position.
|
Just a word missing between the "out" and "his" here--you need to stick the word "of" in there. Be sure to proofread to catch small errors like this--but don't worry too much, because they happen to everyone. ;]
An issue with tenses here:
Quote:
|
Carcaroth, however frustrated he would be with Kerel at the moment, knew that he was right.
|
"Would" here implies the future tense, but in the same sentence, you say he "would be...
at the moment". These two things contradict themselves, since "at the moment" implies the present. I'd suggest replacing "would" with "might" or swapping out "would be" with "could have been".
Just a small nitpick here:
Quote:
|
It was as if Boden could predict his movements, because it was total darkness where they were, and he didn’t think that she could see that well in darkness to get all of his movements.
|
Using the word "movements" twice in this sentence is a tiny bit repetitive. I'd replace the second one with the word "actions".
...And that's all the issues I have with this post! Awesome work---I was really impressed with your fight with Asha towards the end. I felt you portrayed her abilities very well and that Carcaroth's reactions to them were well-written and believable. Kerel added some humor--and I wanted to root for poor Carcaroth the whole time. Very fine writing there. ^___^
Once you fix up the errors I've pointed out, post here and...someone will give you a new lesson. Not sure who yet--but probably Awkin. ^^;;