|
|||
|
Re: Help with Proof
Actually, I take it back; I based that on the idea that if your original answer was wrong, putting it through those formulas would produce a different value, which upon double-checking turned out not to be true; the "proof" is merely a tautology. Clearly I fail at logic today, so I went back and tried it again.
You can use angle complementation and half-angle formulas to make some progress; cos[π/5] = +-√(1 + cos[2π/5]/2) cos[2π/5] = sin[π/2 - 2π/5] = sin[π/10] = +-√(1 - cos[π/5]/2) 2(cos[π/5])^2 - 1 = cos[2π/5] = +-√(1 - cos[π/5]/2) 2(cos[π/5])^2 - 1 = +-√(1 - cos[π/5]/2) 8(cos[π/5])^4 - 8(cos[π/5])^2 + = -1 - cos[π/5] which at least gets the entire thing in terms of cos[π/5]. Double edit: I can change it from a quartic into a cubic, but I doubt that the general solution for either is part of your coursework. The answer implies that it's possible to get the solution in quadratic form, but I can't see a way to do it. There is a way to get a sort-of proof, but I consider it semi-dishonest since the proof relies on plugging in the answer at a certain point (though I checked other answers this time and they don't check out; it will only work if the angle is correct, or with the correct angle times -1 as cosine an even function). I'll post it and let you see if you can divine anything from it, or pick out mistakes: 8(cos[π/5])^2[(cos [π/5])^2 - 1] = -1 - cos[π/5] 8(cos[π/5])^2 = -1 - cos[π/5]/{(cos[π/5])^2 - 1} -8(cos[π/5])^2 = 1 + cos[π/5]/{cos[π/5] + 1}{cos[π/5] - 1} 8(cos[π/5])^2 = 1/(1 - cos[π/5]) 8(sec[π/5])^2 = 1 - cos[π/5] 8(sec[π/5])^2 - 1 + cos[π/5] = 0 8/(cos[π/5])^2 - (cos[π/5])^2/(cos[π/5])^2 + (cos[π/5])^3/(cos[π/5])^2 = 0 8 + (cos[π/5])^3 - (cos[π/5])^2 = 0 (cos[π/5])^2 - (cos[π/5])^3 = 8 (cos[π/5])^2{1 - cos[π/5]} = 8 cos[π/5] = √(8/{1 - cos[π/5]}) At this point, you can substitute (1 + √5)/4 into the equation and it will check out. I've attempted to get a quadratic out of this jumble, but have met with no luck. All my attempts to set two equations for cos[π/5] equal to each other have resulted in aforementioned cubics. |

|
||||
|
Re: Help with Proof
I'm not sure if you still need help, but couldn't you use a triangle that has (pi/5) in it? Kind of like the right-angle triangle with the other 2 angles being (pi/4) and ((square root of 2)/2) for the adjacent and opposite and 1 as the hypotenuse.
__________________
Dance like no one is looking, sing like no one can hear. Love like you've never hurt before, live like there's nothing to fear. -Newsboys |

| Advertisement |
![]() |
| Tags |
| proof |
| Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests) | |
| Thread Tools | |
|
|