What would you rate LoZ:ALttP out of ten?

I haven't played this much but I thought I would go on with the rate out of ten threads.. I would rate 5/10 because I don't really know all the details but I'm starting to play it.

10/10 This game is perfection. The most dungeons, the largest overworld (depending on how you
look at it) great music, dual-world exploration, tons of items, the Sacred Realm, introduced most
of the classic areas (Kakariko Village etc.) After all the Zelda games have gotten too easy, this
game keeps me losing lots of hearts.

The best game, except for maybe OoT. Lovely, just lovely.
For its time, 10/10. Today... still 10/10. Simply amazing.

while it has been a very long time since I played this, and rating it off of my foggy memory I would have to say 9/10, the -1 for just wanting depth to some of the other characters.

Originally Posted by Cukeman

10/10 This game is perfection. The most dungeons, the largest overworld (depending on how you
look at it) great music, dual-world exploration, tons of items, the Sacred Realm, introduced most
of the classic areas (Kakariko Village etc.) After all the Zelda games have gotten too easy, this
game keeps me losing lots of hearts.

QFT

Originally Posted by ZeldaZealot

while it has been a very long time since I played this, and rating it off of my foggy memory I would have to say 9/10, the -1 for just wanting depth to some of the other characters.

...That wasn't really technologically possible back then.

Originally Posted by Cukeman

10/10 This game is perfection. The most dungeons, the largest overworld (depending on how you
look at it) great music, dual-world exploration, tons of items, the Sacred Realm, introduced most
of the classic areas (Kakariko Village etc.) After all the Zelda games have gotten too easy, this
game keeps me losing lots of hearts.

This ^^^

And don't forget the fact you have to re-use weapons you found in earlier dungeons. Hardly any of the new Zelda games have this.

I voted 9/10. The game is an epic masterpiece. Lots of fun, quite challenging, and a good example of the better games of the franchise (Ocarina of Time is another). More of the games should keep that classic medieval/fantasy touch in ALttP, with just different ideas. I don't think Nintendo has figured out how to pull this one off lately.

I liked how ALttP's main plot was told through talking to a lot of NPCs, like in an RPG,
there weren't a lot of NPCs with random useless information, but each one seemed to shed
new light on the plot as an epic whole. In modern Zelda games it seems you only hear the
plot through the main characters, not-so-significant characters usually only talk about
side theories, such as triumph forks and the sheikah. In ALttP each character was a part
of the story. Even non-descript shop owners had explanations such as ties to the forest thieves
or horrible dark world disfigurements. The story of the flute-playing boy that turns into a
vegetable was a great statement about the personal impacts on people's lives of the quest
for the golden power, while at the same time it was very touching.

I guess lots of NPC dialogue is common in RPGs, but ALttP's seemed especially well thought out,
and was concise enough that it didn't get boring. Or so I thought

10/10 this game has REALLY good gameplay and the first few dungeons are relatively easy, but when you get to the other dungeons they can get quite hard.And it has a great story line too.

9/10. Definitely a great game, but a game would have to be godly for me to rate it a 10/10.

Solid 10/10, you can't get any more perfection than this in a zelda game. It has everything you could want: story, music and gameplay.

This one is closest to perfect IMO. It's fantastic and if/when the put the GBA version on DSware, I think a whole new generation of gamers will be made aware.

9/10

One of the greatest games of all time!!

10/10! If only it was in 3D i would without a doubt declare it the greatest game ever made!

Originally Posted by Oni Dark Link

10/10! If only it was in 3D i would without a doubt declare it the greatest game ever made!

It being in 2D is keeping it from being the best game ever? Lol@3Dgenerationgamers.

I'm giving it a perfect 10/10. It is one of the only Zeldas that keeps a consistent theme throughout the game, the Light and Dark World. It was difficult enough to challenge, but not enough to frustrate (unlike AoL). It had a whole ton of dungeons, each one with a great boss that seemed to fit the dungeon perfectly. It has more items than any Zelda game to date, and the items are actually used throughout the game. It has more magic than any Zelda game except AoL, magic that is actually used a lot. It has a compelling story and an actually difficult final boss. The game is great; I can't think of any way to improve it.

Who the hell gave it 5?!

Originally Posted by GreenPhazon

Who the hell gave it 5?!

You could click the numbers and find out. It was TriforceLegacy.

Originally Posted by Triforce of the Gods

It was TriforceLegacy.

I should've read the OP really.

Originally Posted by TriforceLegacy

I haven't played this much but I thought I would go on with the rate out of ten threads.. I would rate 5/10 because I don't really know all the details but I'm starting to play it.

You sholdn't rate things before playing them to the end! In my opinion, it deserves a 10/10.