I'm surprised by how poorly
SS seems to have been received. Some people's opinions I respect, others just have incredibly bad taste. For example, if you share my general antipathy towards
TP, but for what I consider the "wrong" reasons, I have less respect for your opinion than someone I disagree with who reasons well.
I have a sneaking suspicion that much of the negative reaction toward
SS is veiled dislike of the art-style or motion controls. However, detractors do not want to come across as shallow to others or themselves, so they attempt to justify their viewpoint on other grounds, which has led to some hilariously contradictory viewpoints (ex:
SS has no sense of urgency, yet suddenly we're ignoring that this actually describes
TP. In fact,
SS has a more pressing threat than any Zelda outside of
MM).
I just finished the game about an hour ago. I can't understand why people are lukewarm about this game. I seriously question people's judgement, but I guess it all is a matter of opinion in the end.