Ahh, you're right on that.

I mean it seems that it's not bringing any good discussions.

What do you mean by that?

I think theorizing has started to go to the crows...

1. AST shows us that even when Ganondorf is killed, his essence will survive. In which case if we put LoZ/AoL and OoX on the adult timeline before TMC we see:

TWW: Ganondorf dies.
LoZ: Ganondorf's essence dies.
OoX: Ganon is revived then dies.
FSA: He's reborn in time for ALttP.

So really that isn't much of an argument.

3.Kensuke Tanabe, the scriptwriter for ALttP, LA, and OoT produced it. I see that as reason enough for it to be Canon.

1. Because Ganon is dead to the point where he can't resurrect himself at the end of BOTH games. This is why I think the endings are parallel.

2. Okay.

3. But I don't take it as canon.

How exactly does ALttP go inconsistat with LoZ?

Nope that's impossible. The legend of the subrosians happened on mount Desma which we know used to be death mountain. In OoT which we know goes before the split the mountain is death mountain.

Ergo if you take FPTRRL as Canon you're screwed.

This is a good arguement. I don't believe however, that Twinrova can ressurrect herself like Ganon, otherwise she would be present more often, no? I don't consider The Tingle games canon, but even so, couldn't the Subrosian Legend take place before the split? Things that go before the split can last in both timelines. The main reason I don't want to place OoX on the AT with LoZ/AoL is that it goes inconstistant with ALttP, which I don't place on the CT directly after TP for obvious reasons.

Yes however, LoZ/AoL obviosly come before OoX and they make references such as maze island to coming on the adult timeline. Furthermore, FPTRRL without a doubt comes on the adult timeline and it explains the origins of the subrosians, hense by default OoX must come on the adult timeline.

Furthermore if you want an explenation for Twinrova:

1. She says she'll come back to haunt you.
2. Capcom is renouned for their cameo apearances.

What is there to debate? It's pretty straightfoward. Twinrova is alive on CT, so I put OoX there as they are the main villains.