LoZ: Phantom Hourglass out of 10 rating

I'd give it an 8/10 because the storyline is good but the controls kinda suck...And the gameplay is fun.

I beat this game on my friend's DS and it was good... it just was a fun handheld game thats all i can say so Im giving it an 8/10.

Hmm. It's a fantastic game, and there's really nothing wrong with it...
except the Temple of the Ocean King and a few minor things. I'd say 9/10.

It's not my favorite Zelda game, but it still was pretty good. So I give it a 9/10

I give it a 9/10 because I think it's okay the story is fun but I never beat it. Someone stole it from me and I was at the last boss.

I'd give it a 9/10.

It is a good game. Has a good story line, and you'd never get tired of playing it over and over. I've played it, and beaten it at least 3 times now. And it's still fun.

It was good, but I didn't enjoy the stylus the whole time. :/

8/10 I tried it and the Stylus was so hard to control it

I gave it a 7.the game is too easy.

10/10!

I love that game!!!

until some one stole my game...

7 out of 10 for good storyline
but stylus 100% of the time sucked i got bored cuz i could only use 1item at a time unlike OoT&MM
but i did love bellum as the villian XD
but the graphics or celshadin where kinda sad in my opinion,cuz i was expectin 3d but then boom cartoony link lol
but i like the game & im willin to try spirit tracks cuz of it lol

I gave it 2/10 simply because it was my first Zelda game and when I saw what Zelda really was it just sucked. It was dull, easy, and repetitive

10/10 Great Game!

Well PH is the only Zelda game I've played hence have nothing to compare it to, but I give it a 7/10.
Good storyline, alright graphics, the boss's were really fun. Kept me occupied for ages because I'm quite slow with completing these kind of games.
Hopefully getting TP for Christmas, cant wait!

7/10, ti was fun, storyline was good, characters were alright, stylus control was lame

7/10. It was ok, but nothing special.

I gave it a 7/10. I liked it, it had a cool story, but I hated the Temple of the Ocean King... playing it over and over REALLY got old, and I didn't really like the controls all that much. But I'm still excited for Spirit Tracks!

Originally Posted by hero of time 28

I'd give it an 8/10 because the storyline is good but the controls kinda suck...

Isn't it like the total opposite? The storyline was stupid, but the controls were awesome? xD

No, seriously, the most fun with the game came from the controls imho. I don't really get, why people would prefer the boring D-Pad controls instead. The controls are intuitive and fun. And the toon Zelda style definitely worked nice for the NDS. But I thought, the dungeon design wasn't good and the music was kind of lacking.

Originally Posted by IcecreamLink

10/10!

I love that game!!!

until some one stole my game...

I sorta agree. The stylus was annoying.

Yeah. Someone stole mine before I beat it.

I'd give it an 8/10 because the storyline is good but the controls kinda suck...And the gameplay is fun.

I'd give it 8 for the opposite- awesome controls, terrible story!