MC VS PH

witch do you think is better minish cap or phantom hourglass?

Silver is gonna kick your arse for your grammar.

Also MC.

The Minish Cap.

Originally Posted by Zero of Time

Silver is gonna kick your arse for your grammar.

Also MC.

Agree with all statements.

1. I haven't played the MC.
2. I think PH is better. PH is one of the best I think, probably my 3rd favorite.

Also MC.

The Minish Cap.

D.) All of the above.

1. I haven't played the MC.

BLASPHEMY! Play it! Now!

Both are brilliant, but Phantom Hourglass tops The Minish Cap any day of the week. It has customization to your mode of transportation and Wi-Fi Battle mode.

I enjoyed PH way more than TMC...so PH.

Originally Posted by Mukora

BLASPHEMY! Play it! Now!

Why should I? PH I still like pretty much because of the bosses and other aspects. I'd have to spend like $50 dollars for it because I don't have a Gameboy Advance anymore. I don't know anyone with one anyway. In summary, PH will still be better.

I would vote for The Minish Cap all the way, but I didn´t like Phantom Hourglass. Guess I am the wrong person to ask maybe, but if I would choose: The Minish Cap.

I enjoyed both of the games, but I can't really tell which one that I like better.
I would say that I like TMC because I don't have to use the stylus for PH.

PH is much better. Plus MC is too short.

This looks like a job for...
The Grammar Nazi!

Originally Posted by mastrlink

witch do you think is better minish cap or phantom hourglass?

Allow me to point out what is wrong with this blaspheming of the English Language.

1. Witch? Are we talking about Witches? Did they cast a stupidity curse on you or something?

2. Run-on sentences are a massive no. There should be a question mark or a comma after "better, and if there was a question mark, "MC or PH" is still a fragment.

3. Minish Cap and Phantom Hourglass are proper nouns that should be capitalised.

Now to answer the thread question:
They both sucked.

Uh Oh! You've angered the Grammer Nazi!

Originally Posted by FD-Oni Link

1. I haven't played the MC.
2. I think PH is better. PH is one of the best I think, probably my 3rd favorite.

Dude, no. How can you have an honest opinion on the matter, if you've not even played the other game in question?

Originally Posted by Silver

3. Minish Cap and Phantom Hourglass are proper nouns hat should be capitalised.

Nice Nazi work there, Silver.

I do believe the word you were looking for is "that".


Edit: To be on topic, I think TMC is better. I find the gameplay much more enjoyable, find Vaati to be a much better villain, and thought it was much easier on the eyes. Pseudo-3D is something PH shouldn't have wandered into.

Originally Posted by Red

Dude, no. How can you have an honest opinion on the matter, if you've not even played the other game in question?


Nice Nazi work there, Silver.

I do believe the word you were looking for is "that".


Edit: To be on topic, I think TMC is better. I find the gameplay much more enjoyable, find Vaati to be a much better villian, and thought it was much easier on the eyes. Pseudo-3D is something PH shouldn't have wandered into.

And you're the one to tell me. Well, I guess it was good I looked at this post to reply. I can have an opinion and I think PH was really good and TMC would have to be as good as MM if it is better than PH. It can be an honest opinion if I think it's true honestly.

Originally Posted by Red

Nice Nazi work there, Silver.

I do believe the word you were looking for is "that".

PH shouldn't have wandered int

Originally Posted by Some guy

And you're the one to tell me. Well, I guess it was good I looked at this post to reply. I can have an opinion and I think PH was really good and TMC would have to be as good as MM if it is better than PH. It can be an honest opinion if I think it's true honestly.

No, no, no.

You cannot have an honest opinion of which game is better of which game is better until you have played both of them. Saying "I've only tried X, so it's automatically better than Y" doesn't work.

While I personally found both games bad, TMC was less bad. It at least kept me occupied longer than PH did, although that's not hard to do.

Originally Posted by goober man

Uh Oh! You've angered the Grammer Nazi!

*Grammar >.>



I've never played Minish Cap, but I pretty much hate Phantom Hourglass. So it's a tie?

Originally Posted by Silver

No, no, no.

You cannot have an honest opinion of which game is better of which game is better until you have played both of them. Saying "I've only tried X, so it's automatically better than Y" doesn't work.

While I personally found both games bad, TMC was less bad. It at least kept me occupied longer than PH did, although that's not hard to do.

That's your opinion. You're arguing about my honest opinion.

Here's a checklist for my honest opinion:

1. Is it an opinion? Yes.
2. Is my opinion true? Yes.

So, it is an honest opinion.

*sigh*

You just aren't getting it, are you?

It's an opinion, yes. But it's not a fair opinion. Your attitude is pretty much "Out of X and Y, I've only played Y, so it's much better than X."

Which is generally a poor attitude to have anyway, but it also makes you seem quite asinine.