^Fanboys? Hardly. Galaxy deserves that spot, there's no doubt about that. It's not like other games don't deserve it as well though, but Mario Galaxy is far from a game that gets supports from the fans alone.
Why JUST portal? how about the orange box itself? Those are ALL amazing games and it out beat halo 3 in sales in just a matter of weeks. So i voted portal, but The set it comes with is the victor in my opinion
I'm not sure where you get your facts, but the very idea of any 360 game outselling Halo 3 anytime soon is silly.
You really have no idea what you're talking about do you?
Three incredible games, all deserving of a vote in my eyes, and fun as hell to play to boot. I considered Pokemon D/P also, but while that is indeed crazy fun and addictive, something about it is pulling me back from considering it a top game. I have no idea what, and I play it just as much, if not more, than a couple of the games I did vote for, but there you go.
Halo 2. First level, you walk around this yucky space ship and you have to shoot these babyish monsters that don't even look good. They seriously need to get a proper artist on the job.
Also, the poll isnt biased at all. SMG got Game of the Year on IGN, Gamespot and I think Gamespy too. Shows how good babyish mediocre shooters are, aren't they?
Yes the poll is biased because we're on a nintendo fan based site. So obviously SMG is going to get the most votes on this site guaranteed. Just think about it, putting a popular mario game on a poll on a nintendo fan site, on a poll that says game of the year. Yea it's pretty biased if you ask me.
I'm not saying that it doesn't deserve top spot though. It is a great game don't get me wrong.
And this doesn't show how shooters are crap by the way....lol