SSBM-Theory about Link

I have played SSBM for a LONG time, and amazingly just thought of this question to ask people. Should Link's Smash Up-A attack be changed? I think it should.
Most of the time when I was a beginner of the game, everytime I used his
Smash Up-A attack, only one of the 3 swings would actually hit my opponent. I "have" found a way to make it work, but it is still too much trouble.

Now, I ask of you. Who thinks Link's Up-A attack should be changed or reconfigured to hit every swing? Explain why or why not.

I do, your talking about the smash Up, right? Well anyway, it should be changed, it isn't useful, powerful, or even flashy, so it should be changed...

It is absolutely fine as it is. However, it isn't visually pretty to see the eye, but it slightly increases your chane of actually hitting the opponent.
I believe this was mainly designed for those who essentially don't have any specific timing.

The title confused me. I don't wanna be rude, but you know this isn't a theory, right?

Anyway, I don't see the need for a change, but at the same time I wouldn't mind. Right now, I'm looking through the 2 videos of smash bros brawl... and Link does this attack, so they havn't changed it. Not saying they couldn't have done it after the last video was released, but it looks like they're gonna keep it.

I agree with both Alucard and AzKicker... If anything, that move is what makes Link a tiered character. You use this to hit a character into the air, and then jump Up Smash. Believe me....it helps.

Na they should leave it as it is. When they change characters' moves even slightly like that I get thrown out of whack for a while. For ages I hated playing as Kirby in Melee because his running A attack was changed from the original and my brain refused to remember that fact in the middle of a battle.