Ilia Could Be Minda

Think about it. Minda would have to be someone who knows link, and Ilia knows link, so I would not be suprised if it was true. Does anyone agree with me on this?

Midna is evil, and only helps Link because it is advantageous for herself. Ilia is definitely not evil. I mean come on, she was worried over Link pushing the horse too much. That would be one weird evil person.

edit: Well there is one way now that I think about it. Maybe the twilight would corrupt her and make her evil. I still think its not true but your theory is plausible under those conditions.

Thing is, how do we know that midna has ever left the Twilight realm. If she ever does then she probably won't be anyone that link knows, and who says that when and if she does leave the Twilight realm she will turn into a person. I am very anxious to know who/what it is as I have made some very silly suggestions myself. I'm not saying this is a silly suggestion, but I am saying that we can only wait and see.

Originally Posted by chaos2x0

Midna is evil, and only helps Link because it is advantageous for herself. Ilia is definitely not evil. I mean come on, she was worried over Link pushing the horse too much. That would be one weird evil person.

edit: Well there is one way now that I think about it. Maybe the twilight would corrupt her and make her evil. I still think its not true but your theory is plausible under those conditions.

How do you know Midna is evil?

Originally Posted by Thunderslf

How do you know Midna is evil?

Eiji stated himself that Midna was evil.

Originally Posted by Deku_Link530

Eiji stated himself that Midna was evil.

I thought he said thet she is an enemy of some sort.
that's not neccessarily the same thing as her being evil.

Okay. But why does everyone think Illia is Midna? She seems to un important to be Midna.

Here is the interview. Midna is evil and I doubt that she is Midna. They turn into the thing that reflects there personality (I can't say this for sure but if it is like the dark realm at all this is true.) Just look at this:

Originally Posted by IGN (Interview)

As to why he actually becomes a wolf rather than some other creature, obviously Link in every game is a hero. We thought a wolf was what a hero might be in animal form. We kind of decided that wolves are creatures with a certain mysticism in all cultures and they're also very heroic type creatures as well. In that sense, we really felt that the wolf was best suited to an animal representation of the hero.

He says they took how Link acts into concideration for the wolf so with reasoning, when you enter the Twilight Realm you turn into what best suits your personality. So I doubt Midna is Ilia because she isn't evil by nature.

Yeah, I'm pretty sure that the key word was 'enemy,' not 'evil.' Though maybe it was just the translation I read?

Enemy =/= Evil

At least not necessarily.

Originally Posted by Leminnes

Here is the interview. Midna is evil and I doubt that she is Midna. They turn into the thing that reflects there personality (I can't say this for sure but if it is like the dark realm at all this is true.) Just look at this:

He says they took how Link acts into concideration for the wolf so with reasoning, when you enter the Twilight Realm you turn into what best suits your personality. So I doubt Midna is Ilia because she isn't evil by nature.

I see nothing in that article about Midna being evil?

Evil or enemy? It hardly makes the difference does it. And anyway, this thread is about who you think midna might be (more directed at Ilia being midna).

Originally Posted by Snapdragon

I see nothing in that article about Midna being evil?

I just aw the same thng. I got the wrong interview. I have to get the right one, he says it though and I'm absolutly sure about it.

if you read the new NP mag (july issue) it says that When you leave the twilight realm you turn back into your human for and Midna is gone when you enter again you turn into a wolf and Midna is with you again. So Midna isnt Ilia or anyone else for that matter. She is almost nothing in the normal world actually.

I dont actually have the magazine, I read it at a bookstore. If you dont believe me then i guess ill just have to wait until i do get the mag to prove it to you... or someone else does.

I have the mag, it doesn't even mention Ilia, it does say that Midna is nowhere to be found when you leave the Twilight Realm.

I'm glad I found this thread, because I've been wondering forever why Link turns into a wolf over anything else, now I know!

And..I've learned something today!

How do you Midna HAS to be someone Link knows?
A lot of people know Link in the game.

Who is Ilia?

1) Midna is evil, as stated by Nintendo. Illia is obviously not evil.

2) Illia is kidnapped and you don't save Colin until you're about halfway through the game. Odds are, you won't save Illia until close to the end.