What would you rate LoZ:WW out of ten?

Ok so I thought I would make another one so here's Windwaker now...

Anyway this game is fun, I'm really not used to being out on the great sea known as Hyrule so that set me back a bit and the gameplay is fun it has a lot of puzzles and stuff... and another thing I wasn't to fond off is that link is way more cartoonish in this game. But all in all it is still really enjoyable so I would rate it a 7/10!

I like the game, I really loved the fact that they gave Ganondorf more depth so +10 for that alone, -1 for needing the GBA and link cable to get a 100%(its driving me nuts!), and -1 for still not enough monsters on the overworld.

A very good Zelda game. I loved how they gave Ganondorf depth. I also love the style and the story line. However it was far too easy. I gave it a 9.

I gave it a 9 because while it was a very good game, it felt unfinished. I know Water Temples (since OoT) have a notorious reputation but I would have liked to earn Nayru's Pearl. I'm quite sure that Greatfish was destroyed as a way to avoid needing a temple, which was disappointing because I think I would have liked the island. It would have been cool to have a third sage, since we could have had two more temples. (Sage of Ice could have been cool, or something different? ) I wasn't a fan of using the Wind's Requiem all the time just so I could head the other directions, and the Triforce finding was kind of boring. I still think it was good enough for a 9 though, especially since it had an interesting concept.

I give it a 9, pricipally because of the sailing part of the game. It was just boring. Oh and the quest for the pieces of the Triforce was pretty annoying. Another dungeon or so seems a better idea than that.

In the other hand, I think that WW has the best sword combat in the series and the stealth moves were a very refreshing idea.

Nine-and-a-bit. I love everything about it, except the lack of proper dungeons.

Well Windwaker is such a hard game to actually judge.... first off the game was fun fantastic the fighting and boss battles were great. The only down fall really was the sailing.... it was insane! I didn't like that aspect but I still enjoyed it a Zelda game is still a Zelda game. I'll give it a 5...

8.5, rounded up to 9. The Wind Waker is up on my top ten list of favorite graphics in games, it just looks so beautiful and smooth. The graphics are great, the music is great, the characters are incredibly charming, the story is campy, the gameplay and sailing was fun... The only thing bringing it down from a whole nine is the amount of dungeons, it really did feel a bit too short.

Some minus points for "difficulty," too. It would have been nice if the second quest you can start improved the challenge, it was a ridiculously easy game.

9, for pretty much the same reasons as everybody else. I loved that Ganondorf had actual personal reasons for what he was doing, rather than simply "I'm Evil! You Must Die!!!!!!" and I found the story and sense of humor to be some of the best in the Zelda series.

If it wasn't for that Triforce quest at the end and the fact that they cut a few dungeons out, it might have been, just maybe, my best game of all time.

10/10

One of my favorite games and the best Zelda title in my opinion. The world couldn't be portrayed any better, and I have no gripes about the items, characters, enemies, or anything.

A solid 10.

I loved the graphics, they were breathtaking. The music was great, and so were the characters. Sure, it was a bit short, but I'm alright with that.

All in all, it was a fantastic game.

10/10

Loved the story, a bit 'different' than some of the other.
The music was great too, Dragon roost Island FTW~
And the fact they gave the characters depth. Ganondorf is not just that " I want power, time to take over the world!" character in this game. Near the end you kind of feel sad for him..
And last but not least the open world. It could have had a few more islands, but it was still good.

Originally Posted by Tess

Sure, it was a bit short, but I'm alright with that.

It was? It took me around 3 months on my first time, still haven't beaten it a second time, and never got 100% on either.

Originally Posted by Hylian Phantom

It could have had a few more islands, but it was still good.

You wanted over 50 islands? I believe there were a total of 49 in the game. And as it was, some of them didn't have much of a use. There would have just been more of those if there were more islands than that.

I loved it, but I would've preferred more dungeons* instead of the
long ToC quest and the merchant/cabana/flowerpot/auction quests

*and probably smaller dungeons Earth & Wind were dang big,
taking a long time just to walk through

I'd give it a 9/10. It has a terrific art style, a compelling story, and solid gameplay. In fact, aside from Twilight Princess and Ocarina of Time, it'd probably have to be my favorite Zelda game. That said, I absolutely hated the Triforce Chart quest, which brings it down quite a bit for me.

I've always just kinda waved it off until recently. I replayed it before I started Phantom Hourglass, and I had a lot of fun with it. The graphics are pretty sweet, too.

Wind Waker is one of my favourite games ever. The music, the dungeons, the difficulty, the graphics, the interactivity, all of the little things like spoils. Everything about it was just original, I'll never forget Wind Waker- I mean Toon Link is now a seperate character for the Zelda series, that's gotta mean something XD (by seperate character I mean he has his own series, Wind Waker, Phantom Hourglass and Spirit Tracks thus far)

However, I give it 9 due to the triforce hunting bit. I finsihed the game, and then did it again but stopped at the Triforce part because I couldn't be BOTHERED doing it again XD

7.4

I rounded down

Great game, im still in the middle of playing it but Ive had a lot of fun with this game.
And I feel like ive been free to do more exploring on my own for fun. Not long into the game and I was just sailing all over that map to see what was out there.
And I love the graphics, I have no problem with it looking the way it does. Fantastic design.

7/10

I get how some people love it, but I find it incredibly dull. It's not horrible though, and I liked the art direction (in places).