What would you rate LoZ:TP out of ten?

I nice solid 8/10. :D

Great game, worth owning and playing through once or twice. Not exactly a classic like certain other 3D Zelda games, but every game can't be a masterpiece. :]

8/10

A great game really. Good story, good gameplay, good re-play value. The only thing, and this will continue throughout the series I think, is the "N64" syndrome. Ocarina of time (and in my opinion MM) both set the standard so ridiculously high that all the games since them, including TP, have yet to live up. Some have come close, but none have matched it or gone higher.

Originally Posted by sage_of_fire

The only thing, and this will continue throughout the series I think, is the "N64" syndrome. Ocarina of time (and in my opinion MM) both set the standard so ridiculously high that all the games since them, including TP, have yet to live up. Some have come close, but none have matched it or gone higher.

This, for sure. People keep comparing newer games to older games instead of seeing the newer games for what they are.

I would give it a 9. It's a nice story, good graphics, good characters, but, It was too easy.

I rate Eight. Expansive Overworld, Fun Bosses, and a good deal of random fun (For some reason, I ocassionally feel like Riding all the way around Lanaryu, just for the chance to kill something). Loses 1 point for havin to re-navigate a dungeon after you quit, and another for the sheer difficulty of Water based puzzles (Zora Temple, Fishing ETC).

Originally Posted by Jedi Of Nayru

Loses 1 point for havin to re-navigate a dungeon after you quit,

Then don't quit in the middle of a dungeon.

Originally Posted by Jedi Of Nayru

and another for the sheer difficulty of Water based puzzles (Zora Temple, Fishing ETC).

How is fishing difficult?

Originally Posted by Link92

Then don't quit in the middle of a dungeon.



How is fishing difficult?

Hey hey guess what! TWILIGHT PRINCESS IS NOT ****ING GOD! Oh, and these are people's opinions.

Oh, and by the way, some of us having higher priorities in life than video games, so the whole save quit thing in the middle of a dungeon is kinda important. Although I'd like to note that due to the linearity of TP's dungeons that whole save and go back to start thing was just a time eater, and also that stupid chicken thing was there for that.

And motion controls for fishing can be annoying at times, but fair enough it is kinda easy.

Originally Posted by Link92

This, for sure. People keep comparing newer games to older games instead of seeing the newer games for what they are.

I do see it for what it is. A mediocre, empty, and silly experience

How is fishing difficult?

Like everything else in the game, it's not.

Some reviewer (can't remember who) made a good point about TP. he said that since Zelda is going in a totally different direction and that it will never be the same, Nintendo wanted fans to have one last game with the classic formula in it, to brush by some nostalgia, and give fans "one last good-bye" to the old formula. If that's the case, fine, but I personally don't feel it's neccessary. The old games will never go away; it's not like they'll just disappear forever.

I rate TP a 7.8

I say that becuase of how easy it was(-2)
and
something else that slipped my mind(-0.2)

Originally Posted by Talhoffer

Hey hey guess what! TWILIGHT PRINCESS IS NOT ****ING GOD! Oh, and these are people's opinions.

Someone really needs to calm down. I never said it was God. If you payed attention instead of acting like such a sensitive idiot, you would know that I have already named quite a few flaws in TP.

Originally Posted by Link92

Someone really needs to calm down.

No I just figured that since you are so dense cap locks might get through to you better.

I never said it was God.

Actions speak louder than words.

If you payed attention instead of acting like such a sensitive idiot,

I am many things, but sensitive on the interlulz? That I am not.

you would know that I have already named quite a few flaws in TP.

And you still love the game undyingly.

Originally Posted by Talhoffer

No I just figured that since you are so dense cap locks might get through to you better.

Actions speak louder than words.


I am many things, but sensitive on the interlulz? That I am not.



And you still love the game undyingly.

Interlulz. Interlulz. I like lolcats. Interlulz.

I know this argument is really none of my business, so I'm going to not really bother with it.
I'm quoting you to ask you a question because I see this in every last one of your posts:
Why do you always post like a stuck-up pretentious asswad? 'Cause I know damn well you don't talk like that outside of the "interlulz."

And you know what? Screw it. I am gonna jump in on this argument. What the hell does "Actions speak louder than words" have to do with this? Sounds like you just realized you ****ed up because you made an assumption and jumped on Link92 for it.
God damn, man.

Oh my god.

The TP haters think that the TP likers worship TP.

The TP likers think that the TP haters loathe TP with every fiber of their being.


GET THE **** OVER IT FOOLS!!! YOU'RE BOTH WRONG

I'd give it a 6.

While OoT was really easy, I'd have to say that TP(/TWW) was(/were) even easier. I died a few times in OoT, and now if I playthrough it I make actually have one or two deaths, despite knowing the game really well. I killed myself to see what the game over screen looked like in TP. And MM wasn't quite difficult in the same way as, say, AoL, but it REALLY made you think at some parts. Way more than OoT or TP.

The plot was bland and way too similar to LttP and FSA and OoT (OoT is guilty of this too, however. Although I'd say to a lesser extent).

Gameplay was NOT as good as OoT/MM's. Running was slow, you didn't get the option to call Epona any time until late-ish in the game, they nerfed side-jumping and walking backwards, so you couldn't just run backwards/sideways everywhere to get places faster, so it felt way slower. So it was annoying as hell to run everywhere.

And the vines in TP were ****ING STUPID. IT TAKES WAY TOO GOD DAMN LONG TO CLIMB VINES IN TP.

This might seem minor, but it's not. Anyone notice how much hate random tripping in Brawl gets, but how SO very rarely the trip actually changes a match (really only makes a difference if you're fighting against a competent Ice Climber player, or if you're getting down to last hits in a match (which it's your fault for getting hit so much that it gets to that, in the first place))? Both are just annoying as hell. TP vines take way too god damn long to climb. It's so damn stupid that he has to move each limb individually just to climb some damn vines. It's so much damn slower than OoT.

And the tears of light quests were SO FREAKEN DULL.

It had some good parts, which is why I gave it a 6.

^^ While I agree with some parts, I have to say it's total BS that TP's movement is slower than OoT/MM's. In fact, TP's movement is much faster.

actually table, every complaint you just made was really minor.

Originally Posted by Link92

^^ While I agree with some parts, I have to say it's total BS that TP's movement is slower than OoT/MM's. In fact, TP's movement is much faster.

Not counting Wolf Link's dash, and the travel-based emphasis on the unarguably faster Epona.

Originally Posted by Table

The plot was bland and way too similar to LttP and FSA and OoT (OoT is guilty of this too, however. Although I'd say to a lesser extent).

Woah, woah, what? OoT's story is far more similar to ALTTP than TP is to ALTTP or OoT. You get 3 Spiritual Stones/Pendants to get the Master Sword and then awaken 7 maidens, this time under the guise of Sages.

TP was more original in terms of story progression in that none of the dungeons had anything to do with unlocking the Master Sword or awakening Sages.

Originally Posted by Table

Gameplay was NOT as good as OoT/MM's. Running was slow, you didn't get the option to call Epona any time until late-ish in the game, they nerfed side-jumping and walking backwards, so you couldn't just run backwards/sideways everywhere to get places faster, so it felt way slower. So it was annoying as hell to run everywhere.

TP's movement was actually much faster. Not even counting wolf form. It's just that the world was much larger so it took more time to reach certain areas.

Originally Posted by Table

And the vines in TP were ****ING STUPID. IT TAKES WAY TOO GOD DAMN LONG TO CLIMB VINES IN TP.

You have no idea how much I agree with this. Especially when the nunchuck (although it rarely does this) mistakes your control stick movements, making Link climb down and fall to his death when I'm quite clearly trying to climb horizontally.

Originally Posted by Table

Anyone notice how much hate random tripping in Brawl gets, but how SO very rarely the trip actually changes a match (really only makes a difference if you're fighting against a competent Ice Climber player, or if you're getting down to last hits in a match (which it's your fault for getting hit so much that it gets to that, in the first place))? Both are just annoying as hell.

Am I the only one who thinks the hatred of tripping in Brawl is completely justified? It's not that it endangers you of losing the match, it's that it happens WAY TOO OFTEN!!! I agree completely, it's annoying as hell and can cause what would potentially be a really flashy, kick ass combo to fail because some ***whole game designer who's laughing his *** off thinks it was a good idea to make people trip, probably to give the casual ****s a free point.

Originally Posted by Table

And the tears of light quests were SO FREAKEN DULL.

They're not my favorite parts of the game, either.

Originally Posted by Table

It had some good parts, which is why I gave it a 6.

You and I have some differing opinions, I guess it's how we weigh certain flaws. I give TP a 10/10 because I feel it's pros far outweigh its cons, but I don't consider a 10/10 to be a perfect game, just a game of my highest recommendation.

i would rate it a 9.5 because the action great, characters great, story was okay, evil people Zant was awesome but ganon was... disappointing for me the final battle was awesome but i liked the battle with Zant more

remember thats just me