What would you rate LoZ:TP out of ten?

A 7 doesn't sound enjoyable at all.

I gave it a seven. I really can't see how anyone could give it a ten or below a six. The game is obviously not perfect, so giving it a ten, I believe, is just not really thinking it through. Likewise for giving a score below six; yeah, it wasn't great, but hell, below a six is getting into cheap Wii shovelware territory. I give it a seven because that's a fair score to give a game that was a letdown, but not an utter failure.

The game is obviously not perfect, so giving it a ten, I believe, is just not really thinking it through

A 10 doesn't have to be perfect. I like Twilight Princess more than all but 2 games, so to me it is above the normal range. It's beyond 10. Most Zelda games are beyond 10 to me. TP's like a 50 out of 10. MM like a 100 out of 10 and OoT's an infinity out of ten.

Originally Posted by Zeldablue777

A 10 doesn't have to be perfect.

In most circles, yeah, a ten has to be perfect. If a game isn't perfect, then it scores below ten; it's easy. It makes sense that way, too.

Well, yay, I've gotten a 100 on my math test. It doesn't mean I'm perfect. It doesn't even mean I know everything about chapter 4. And if 10 is perfect then I think Twilight Princess is above "perfect" not based off of a check list, but based on the excitement in put me through.

Originally Posted by Zeldablue777

A 10 doesn't have to be perfect. I like Twilight Princess more than all but 2 games, so to me it is above the normal range. It's beyond 10. Most Zelda games are beyond 10 to me. TP's like a 50 out of 10. MM like a 100 out of 10 and OoT's an infinity out of ten.

By this logic, any game receiving a 100% should feel ashamed, but then you also rank MM below TP, so you are invalid. Please, do me a favor and don't review games. Hyperbole in judgments based on numerical values doesn't work if you go much higher than double the original perfection mark.

i give it a 10 because where it lacks in difficulty it makes up for everywhere else

Originally Posted by Talhoffer

By this logic, any game receiving a 100% should feel ashamed, but then you also rank MM below TP, so you are invalid. Please, do me a favor and don't review games. Hyperbole in judgments based on numerical values doesn't work if you go much higher than double the original perfection mark.

100 > 50

I rank it a 10/10, but that has nothing to do with perfection on my own personal scale. I consider a 10/10 to be a game of my absolute highest recommendation, not a perfect game, as TP is not without its flaws.

Love the game, but ZWW is a little better for it's time. 9.

If you compare it to other Zelda's, I gave it a 7/10. The three points i didn't give it were because 1. it was not the challenge I was hoping for; 2. it didn't have great sidequests; and 3. it wasn't very unique. Though it certainly isn't my favorite, it was still an enjoyable experience that any Zelda fan would enjoy.

Those of you giving it a 1 are just overreacting. I understand why some disliked this game, but come on, you're being arrogant.

I voted six.

I think it's a ten. The gameplay is so good I just had to go high

Eight point Eight

Originally Posted by calc84maniac

100 > 50

Well excuuuuuuuse me princess.

Even still, my point still stands.

Originally Posted by Navi the Fairy

Eight point Eight

xD Lol

That's not even funny.


Actually it's a hilarious, good one.

100 > 50

Owned.

Saying how I've enjoyed Ocarina of Time, Majora's Mask and Twilight Princess more than any other game...not to mention I've played these game more than any other, I dont see the problem in regarding them as the best.

I voted 8/10. I thought it was a solid game. Good controls, very good story, but I wish there had been more in the way of side quests. It would've been nice to see Link do more than just save the world.

I'll give the GC TP a 8,5, great game, quite enjoyed it.
The wii version a 7 or less, the controls were horrible, and the only good out of it was aiming.

Twilight Princess was an excellent game. The thing that I loved about it most was the heavy use of art in the game such as the vibrant colours and architect designs.

Although, there are some moments where I believe they could have changed it or simply got rid of it. It's hard to have a completely flawless game these days with the rate of technology going through the roof everyday.

While I know that there are people out there that automatically label TP as a 'direct rip-off from OoT,' it really is a different game to OoT. Sure there is that Deja vu feeling in the game sometimes, but most of it is unique. Most Zelda games are similar to each other in a way anyway.

In the end, I gave TP a 9 out of 10.