Twilight Princess or Wind Waker?

Vote: The Wind Waker.

Twilight Princess was a good game, but not a very good Zelda. Unlike TWW.

Wind Waker all the way!

While Twilight Princess was a good game, I never really got immersed into it like I was with WW.

With respect for each title, the wind waker takes the cake. It just supprised me how awsome it was, with its celtic-pirate feel,, the soundtrack, and the overall design. If certain people hate the game because Link is cartoonish then fists to them! seriously, the game was fantastic!

I like TP more because it felt more like a traditional Zelda game. WW didn't feel very Zelda to me with the whole Spongebob Squarepants butt pirate storyline and was not as immersive as TP was IMO.

Originally Posted by Ganonslayer2000

I like TP more because it felt more like a traditional Zelda game. WW didn't feel very Zelda to me with the whole Spongebob Squarepants butt pirate storyline and was not as immersive as TP was IMO.

Butt pirate?

Wind Waker has its qualities. Graphically one of the best looking GC games. Mini-games and things to do apart from the main quest was plentiful, lots of games in Windfall and around the Ocean. Downside was the Triforce quest, Sailing and the lack of inhabited Islands and the length of main story.

Twilight Princess had a great story, bit let down in places. As for things to do apart from the main quest, less than Wind Waker. This didn't even have a shooting gallery (OOT, MM and WW had one). The Fishing area is much improved. The areas around the main story inc side quests and mini-games let this down a bit, even though there were quite a lot of things to do apart from the main story.

Out of both titles, i can't pick one as the better as both had faults to them. I liked them both the same.

Originally Posted by Enuf3

Butt pirate?

I have nothing against gay people. To each his/her own in sexual preference I always say. Its just the storyline of WW was not that great IMO and it was a little lame and corny. WW was a good game but not as good as TP or OOT IMO.

Originally Posted by Jimes

Wind Waker has its qualities. Graphically one of the best looking GC games. Mini-games and things to do apart from the main quest was plentiful, lots of games in Windfall and around the Ocean. Downside was the Triforce quest, Sailing and the lack of inhabited Islands and the length of main story.

Twilight Princess had a great story, bit let down in places. As for things to do apart from the main quest, less than Wind Waker. This didn't even have a shooting gallery (OOT, MM and WW had one). The Fishing area is much improved. The areas around the main story inc side quests and mini-games let this down a bit, even though there were quite a lot of things to do apart from the main story.

Out of both titles, i can't pick one as the better as both had faults to them. I liked them both the same.

Wind Waker had a shooting gallery?

Originally Posted by Ganonslayer2000

WW didn't feel very Zelda to me with the whole Spongebob Squarepants butt pirate storyline

What?

The Wind Waker did not have a pirate story. It was a story of a boy who left the safety of his home island to save his sister. The pirate crew was a small part of the story, with Tetra getting more airtime towards the end, but the actual crew was not the main focus.

Get your facts straight before talking about the best Zelda game again, boy.

Originally Posted by Ganonslayer2000

I have nothing against gay people. To each his/her own in sexual preference I always say. Its just the storyline of WW was not that great IMO and it was a little lame and corny. WW was a good game but not as good as TP or OOT IMO.

I couldn't care less about your views on gay people.. I'm just trying to figure out where butt pirates fit into WW.

Teh Wind Waker.

Cause it was more my style.

I voted "Twilight Princess."

Originally Posted by Enuf3

I couldn't care less about your views on gay people.. I'm just trying to figure out where butt pirates fit into WW.

Oh OK...I just don't like the whole ARRRGHHH!!! SHIVER ME TIMBERS AND WALK DA PLANK AND AHOY THERE MATEY UPSIDE THE POOPDECK AND IN THE REAR END...storyline of WW. Is that OK with you sir? Your not going to hit me are you?

Originally Posted by SUPER TOTT

What?

The Wind Waker did not have a pirate story. It was a story of a boy who left the safety of his home island to save his sister. The pirate crew was a small part of the story, with Tetra getting more airtime towards the end, but the actual crew was not the main focus.

Get your facts straight before talking about the best Zelda game again, boy.

OMG!! Its the unbelievable WW fanboy!!! Run for your lives!!!

Originally Posted by Ganonslayer2000

Oh OK...I just don't like the whole ARRRGHHH!!! SHIVER ME TIMBERS AND WALK DA PLANK AND AHOY THERE MATEY UPSIDE THE POOPDECK AND IN THE REAR END...storyline of WW. Is that OK with you sir? Your not going to hit me are you?

I would like to. But no.

You don't like the pirates... I don't like the stinkin wolf bs in TP.

We both have hate... But lucky for you and everyone else, I'm not in the mood to argue it. *shrugs* I blame the headache.

The Wind Waker, because I enjoyed its gameplay and atmosphere more. It felt more lighthearted and adventurous, and I loved it also because Zelda had a huge role, and she's my favorite character.

I liked both for different reasons. Twilight Princess is my favorite, mainly because of its story and mature style. The cartoon-ish thing never sat well with me. The Wind Waker, though, I feel, really had that old-timey Zelda feel that I really love. It had a classic ALttP feel to it that I just cannot get over. They are both good for different reasons, but if I had to pick one, definitely TP. The Wind Waker is in my top 5, I must say.

Originally Posted by Enuf3

I would like to. But no.

You don't like the pirates... I don't like the stinkin wolf bs in TP.

We both have hate... But lucky for you and everyone else, I'm not in the mood to argue it. *shrugs* I blame the headache.

(Howls at you) Don't get me wrong TP had its flaws, its just I like the more traditional Zelda feel of TP than the more different sailing the 7 seas pirate theme of WW thats all.

Originally Posted by Ganonslayer2000

OMG!! Its the unbelievable WW fanboy!!! Run for your lives!!!

Stating a fact makes someone a fanboy?

You're even more stupid than I thought.

WW has a pirate plot?

wat

Not really a pirate plot but more of a corny and cheeseball pirate THEME. ARRRGHH SHIVER ME TIMBERS MATEY!!! How lame. If the pirate theme had been more Pirates of the Carribean and less Spongebob Squarepants I probably would have liked WW more.

As for you Super Tott, since you have resorted to personal insults I wish I could meet you in person so I can beat the crap out of you and take a crap on all your WW plush toys, figurines and WW related accessories that all you lame WW fanboys collect.