Midna spinoff

Would anyone here want Nintendo to make a Midna spinoff game?
I think that a Midna spinoff game could have potential.
Thank about it, it could start right after Zant turned her into a imp, and end just before she first meets Link.
So does anyone think that a Midna spinoff is a good idea?

Such a story would offer no real closure. So no.

Midna is one of the few semi-original elements of TP, and overuse of that could further extend my hatred of Nintendo.

While it could have about a "Daxter" potential, I don't think there would be a large enough gap in time between those two events for it to have such potential, as opposed to the 2 years in between Jak 2's prelude and beginning.

Let's not have Zelda become Mario.

Shouldn't this go in the "Spinoff and Cameos" section?

Originally Posted by VictorZamora

Shouldn't this go in the "Spinoff and Cameos" section?

No, since it is about a potential future Zelda game idea.

No

I'd like to see her appear again in another game, because she's awesome. But a spin-off? We've had such things with Tingle... I won't even finish the sentence.

Have we seen a Medli spinoff?

No

Have we seen a Navi spinoff?

No

Have we seen a Ruto spinoff?

No

Midna is just another semi main character, she's not getting a spinoff based around her.

Just no.
There's no real story between the time she's banished and the time she meets Link.

Originally Posted by TheLastRito

Have we seen a Medli spinoff?

No

Have we seen a Navi spinoff?

No

Have we seen a Ruto spinoff?

No

Midna is just another semi main character, she's not getting a spinoff based around her.

Midna is arguably the most important sidekick to ever appear in a Zelda game, and without a doubt the most powerful.

Regardless, no spin-offs plz

Originally Posted by Abyss Master

Midna is arguably the most important sidekick to ever appear in a Zelda game, and without a doubt the most powerful.

Regardless, no spin-offs plz

Key word being sidekick.

comparing midna to any other sidekick is an insult to her.

Midna's Mansion?

... Nah, but seriously, the idea has some potential. But I'd rather just see a new Zelda game with her. Zelda is a very pure franchise, and it can't handle too many spin-offs. Mario can be played around with and that works, but with Zelda you need to tread very carefully.

Originally Posted by Arjen

Midna's Mansion?

... Nah, but seriously, the idea has some potential. But I'd rather just see a new Zelda game with her. Zelda is a very pure franchise, and it can't handle too many spin-offs. Mario can be played around with and that works, but with Zelda you need to tread very carefully.

You do make a good point that unlike Mario, Zelda does have to tread more carefully.
But on the other hand there's a little bit of a gap between when Midna is turned into a imp and when she first meets Link.
TP only showed a few quick scenes(her being turned,her finding the Fuse Shadow helmet)which I think can be expanded on.

i dont think it is a good idea i will like to see her in another zelda game

There shouldnt be a Midna spinoff.
And how did Mario get into this conversation?
There should be another game with Midna in it, just not a game based entirely around her.

No, a Midna-based game would not work.

I can't even think up of any worthwhile game mechanics for this hypothetical game to have.

she left when she became an imp, and remember she could fly, so it wouldnt hav taken her very long, i can see an hour long game

I would much rather prefer a second zelda game with Midna as your sidekick again. Something like what you described would be ok for DLC for TP, but not as a real game.