|
|
#1 |
|
|
#2 |
|
... sold her soul to Murtagh and Anti-Shur'tugal
![]() Join Date: Apr 2005
Location: Ensconced in a library
Posts: 1,940
|
I like the tone the prologue sets, and the brevity of the exposition: just enough to prime and inform the reader, and not so dry or so long as to bore him. For some odd reason, I really liked the last line of the first paragraph: "That all happened between 2006 to 2013, the year is now 2018." The tone, for me, seems almost ominous.
And I must say, the conclusion of chapter 1 was undoubtedly intriguing. Why will this shift be his longest shift? What will cause it to be so? What will happen during it? After? But first things first: Punctuation, punctuation, punctuation! As well as a a verb ending: Quote:
Dispatch with the sudden appearances. There were two instances of suddenly appearing people/things: the train at the beginning of the chapter, appearing from the nothingness, and Jim. While you did offer readers a "heads-up" regarding the train (in showing Ash thinking and complaining about it), the train's appearance is too sudden ("… the humming of the train was getting louder.") "Was getting louder?" thinks the bewildered reader. "But there never was any humming to get louder to begin with!" An essential bit of information is skipped (you go from no sign of the train to the train's hum growing louder), and the reader is thrown off course, distracted. But it's a situation easily fixed. You might write, for example, Quote:
Because you don't introduce Jim until after the dialogue—and the dialogue introduces him in such a sudden, murky way—readers are left to wonder what's happening. When we finally do meet Jim, he seems to have materialized from the nothingness. The affect is most distracting. But again! easily fixed: Quote:
Make use of dialogue tags to enrich story, character, and character interaction: Judging by the guard's reaction to Ash saying, "No, this is a social call," I suspect that Ash's words were somewhat sarcastic. But the way in which their exchange is written didn't give me the impression that Ash was joking. The flavour of that entire passage is lost; it's like listening a tennis match with your eyes closed, with every sound but that of the ball being smacked from one side of the court to the other blocked out. Readers aren't given any sense of the characters engaged in the conversation; it's a bland "he said this, he said that, he said this…" with the meat of character interaction removed, leaving the mere bone. What are the characters doing as they speak? What are their expressions? Their tone of voice? While it's not vital that for every conversation you delve into the actions of the characters, it would definitely enrich your writing if you mixed action and dialogue. You have a handle on depicting character action, and you have a handle on character dialogue: now all you have to do is put the two together. Rather than, Quote:
Quote:
Going back, for a moment, to Jim and Ash's conversation: I think it would be wonderful if you used that passage to experiment with combining dialogue and non-dialogue, and through that combination show to readers what good friends Ash and Jim are. Rather than telling readers that, "they had been best friends for years now", show us through their dialogue, through the "general things" they talk about "which would be useless to list here" (and speaking of that line, I must lift my voice and disagree. If you took but one of those general subjects and showed readers the conversation Ash and Jim had upon it, it would cement the fact of their friendship in the minds of readers, as well as enrich their characters and your writing and story.) Much luck with your story. I hope this critique is helpful, =)
__________________
Last edited by Selah; 03-15-2008 at 06:34 AM. |
|||||||||
|
|
|
|
|
#3 |
|
|
#4 |
|
... sold her soul to Murtagh and Anti-Shur'tugal
![]() Join Date: Apr 2005
Location: Ensconced in a library
Posts: 1,940
|
I edited my last comment, now that I'm on a home computer. Several points I mentioned there, such as run-ons and dialogue, apply to this chapter as well.
Well, this story certainly is growing interesting. I'm really liking the events that are occurring; you have a good sense of heightening the plot and getting to the core of the action.
=D
__________________
|
|||||
|
|
|
|
|
#5 |
|
Deku Scrub
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: Ashford
Posts: 18
|
Great Story can't wait for the next bit
Ashley Johnston |
|
|
|
| Sponsored Links |
|
|
#6 |
![]() |
«
Previous Thread
|
Next Thread
»
| Thread Tools | |
|
|
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:29 AM.






