Okay, so since I'm so far behind, and I'm really not too keen on catching up on a prologue and nine chapters, I'm just going to critique each chapter as I read it, starting with the prologue.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Veyrael
I watched from above cars race across the Golden Gate bridge
|
I get what you're saying here, but I think either you're missing a punctuation mark, or it needs rewording to be more clear. I had to read through it a couple times to see what you were saying. Unfortunately, the way it is, I'm not really sure what the punctuation is, if that's what it needs. Perhaps just rewording it would make it flow better.
Quote:
|
As the light shimmered of the waters
|
I do believe you mean
off the waters.
Quote:
|
Most of all, of that fateful eve when everything finally changed.
|
Although you're clearly going for mystique with this intro, I'm not sure if the "finally" is appropriate in this sentence. Since we hardly know this character, saying "finally" seems out of place, and might confuse the reader. I sure don't know what it's talking about. There's a fine line between a mystically intrigued audience, and a confused one, and I think this might cross that line, though that's just my opinion. This is a really subjective concept anyways. Really small thing, I know, but just something I noticed.
Quote:
|
In such a world as ours, you either possess power or you do not. Power is a double-edged sword
|
The flow is a little broken here, as I think the word "power" is used just one too many times. Try reading it out loud, and you might see how it would sound repetitive.
Quote:
|
Like seven others besides myself, I too am the unfortunate recipient of power. Within my body flows the power of an otherworldly Hero.
|
Same deal here. Perhaps find a replacement word or two for power? Thesauruses are your friends.
Quote:
|
There is no place that his power does not reach; it touches every aspect of my being- my heart, my mind, my blood...even my soul. When I received this power, it too came at a terrible price- it cost me my humanity. Though my heart is still human, I only bear a vague resemblance to the person I once was.
|
And now it's time to give credit where credit is due. This is very well written, I think. The flow and pacing of the sentence structure is very even. It gives just the right amount of mystique to intrigue the audience, but isn't overly confusing. Well done.
Quote:
|
Oh, they were weak at first, but as I became older, the power became stronger. Power, however, becomes destructive when one cannot control it;
|
You need to find an alternative word to power, me thinks.
Quote:
|
As I pull out a sword from the scabbard on my back, I gazed at my reflection and into a face I do and do not recognize.
|
I do believe there is a change of tense here.
Quote:
|
No longer did I have just the weight of my own power crushing my spirit, but I now also had the weight of another's deeply entwined with my soul.
|
Odd. Firefox is telling me that "another's" is a misspelling, but I don't think so. Thought I'd mention it just in case though.
Quote:
|
I was like a phoenix, a being burned by its own power only to rise again once more.
|
I think a semicolon would be more appropriate than a comma in this case.
Quote:
|
Some days, I ask myself, "where did everything go wrong? Why was I the one cursed with this power?"
|
I could be wrong, but I think that the comma after days is unnecessary. Also, the "w" in "where" should be capitalized, as it is the beginning of the character's speech, even if not the beginning of the sentence.
Quote:
|
Yet the answer is so simple...it stemmed from a simple question.
|
This is just
really nitpicky, but there should be a space after an ellipsis.
Quote:
|
My meeting with them was forever engrained into my memory, just as the Hero's power was engrained into my flesh.
|
Again, gotta give credit. This is well written. It flows very well, and just leaves the audience with a sense of epicness. I can tell that this story is going to shake the very foundations of the universe you've created.
Quote:
|
Just as the thought crossed my mind, I landed with a thud on something solid. Whatever it was, I couldn't see; it was as though I was standing on thin air. I staggered to my feet as I tried to regain my bearings. I looked around the void, hoping to find something else there. All that met my gaze was the empty darkness.
|
Do you see how many times you used "I" in that paragraph? Now, you're writing from a first perspective, which gives you the disadvantage of having only a very small handful of pronouns with which to identify your character. This being the case, it is imperative that you don't overuse them. Reword your sentences, and shift your prose around so you identify yourself in a different manner each time. For example, instead of saying: "I looked around the void, hoping to find something else there. All that met my gaze was the empty darkness" say, "Looking around the void, hoping to find something else there, my gaze met by nothing but the empty darkness." This not only keeps your self-identifying pronouns down, but can often cut down how often you put periods and sentence breaks in.
Again, a space after the ellipsis.
Quote:
|
The voices continued to speak. As they spoke, I could vaguely make out my name being spoken.
|
Consult a thesaurus, me thinks. Although speak, spoke, and spoken are all different words, they still sound repetitive when said in such close proximity to each other. Say the sentence out loud and you'll see what I mean.
Quote:
|
"Who's there?!" I asked, unassured by these circumstances.
|
Again, Firefox says this is misspelled, but I really don't believe it.
Quote:
|
"Will you live? Or will you die?" I felt completely taken aback by their questions.
|
Again, this is really nitpicky, but it seems that these are two sentences. In which case, there should be a paragraph break after the quotation.
Quote:
|
"What do you mean?" One of figures- a tall being with a red tinted aura- lifted her hands up into the air.
|
Again, these appear to be two different sentences to me, in which case you need the paragraph break after the quote. Also, I think you mean to have "the" in between "of" and "figures".
Quote:
|
Above us, an image appeared. Visions of shadows unlike any I had seen before raged and snarled above us. Stars, suns, and entire planets became blackened husks of their former selves.
|
Excellent word choice here. Your imagery is fantastic, and really portrays what you're trying to get across to the reader.
Quote:
|
"What are you saying? Are these...'demons' going to destroy the Earth?"
|
Again, space after the ellipsis. Also, if a "the" precedes "earth", it should be a lower case "e". However, if you remove "the", then the upper case "e" is permissible.
Quote:
|
"You are one of the few souls of your world that possesses the Soul-Gatherer's light." My eyes widened.
|
This one I know is two sentences. Paragraph break after the quote.
Me? Possessing a 'light'? What the hell were they talking about?
Quote:
|
"Stop..." I said between gasps of air, "Please...stop..."
|
Space after the ellipsis. Excepting of course it is followed by a quotation mark. Then I do believe that there is not supposed to be a space. However, the one after please needs a space following it.
Quote:
|
I could see the eerie light that flared around it, glowing radiantly like a sun in the darkness of the night.
|
There is nothing grammatically wrong with this, but it just sounds odd. The sun is not out at night. There is no way that any of us can draw a comparison with a notion that is decidedly impossible. I would choose a different word. Space might be a better choice. We've all seen a picture of our sun floating in space, but seeing the sun at night just doesn't work. By definition, when the sun is out, it isn't night.
Quote:
|
As I thought about it a little more, I realized that the light that surrounded the comet...and the light that snaked out of my body were very similar. Were they...one and the same? I cringed at the thought.
|
I'm not really sure if that first ellipsis is appropriate. It seems to me like a comma would work better there, but this is just a matter of personal taste. In any case, it needs a space after it. And as for the second one, you've finally got a space, you just put it before the ellipsis instead of after.
Quote:
|
If I possessed such a light...what did that make me? Was I...even human?
|
These ellipses are lonely without their space brethren.
Quote:
|
Only by combing your strength with that of our Chosen can you hope to drive it back from whence it came." I rubbed my temples in frustration.
|
I do believe you mean "combining", rather than "combing". Also, there should be a paragraph break after the quote.
Quote:
|
"...What do you want from me?! Why did you bring me here?! Why do you keep telling me these things?! I don't understand any of this at all!" I wanted to cry. I wanted to scream.
|
I just thought I should warn you, that after all these ellipses needing spaces after them, this one doesn't, because it begins the sentence.
Quote:
|
"It is not our desire to snuff out your life, mortal. But there is little time.
|
After your lush use of language before, "snuff out" seems oddly informal and out of place. Also, this should really be one sentence, with a comma after "mortal", rather than a period.
Quote:
|
Make your choice now...or we shall make it for you." I was so terrified at this point.
|
I think you know what I'm going to say, but just in case: the ellipsis needs a space, and the quotation needs a paragraph break after it.
Quote:
|
I also remembered my friends, who were eager to get together and have fun- but I also remembered other things.
|
Again, this informal language seems oddly out of place after the descriptive terms you've been using.
Quote:
|
My parents laying near lifeless on a hospital bed, machines their only lifeline.
|
I do believe there are some missing commas in this sentence. The way I see it, it can go two ways. Either you can place one comma after "parents", or you can place two commas around "near lifeless". I do believe one or the other must be chosen though. There needs to be a pause somewhere in there. You choose which, depending on what part of the sentence you want to emphasize.
Quote:
|
Planks of wood breaking apart before caving in. And items around my house moving without my knowledge.
|
I think this should be one sentence. Change the period after "in" to a comma. Although, you could be trying to separate these two ideas, and thus that's why you have a sentence break, rather than making it a compound sentence. So, just in case it isn't that, I guess I'll point it out anyways.
Guessed what I'm going to say? You need a space after your ellipsis.
Quote:
|
I possessed a power. How could I forget this power? It was a power I could not control...a power I wanted to be rid of.
|
Power power power. Although I think I know why you did this, if you read the sentences out loud, I think you'll see just how repetitive it is. Using the same word can have a very dramatic effect, but I think you're overusing it. Consult a thesaurus, would be my recommendation. Also, space after the ellipsis.
Quote:
|
My lack of control of this ability was what put them in that bed. I am the reason they were in a coma. For this reason, I wasn't sure if I deserved to live.
|
Kudos. You found a way to slip some character development into what is an otherwise plot driven paragraph. This is really the best way to do things. If you can accomplish both in one fell swoop, it makes your story that much tighter and complete.
Quote:
|
There were so many things I had yet to do, and so many things that still needed to be done. If I died...
|
If an ellipsis is placed at the end of a sentence, there should be a period following it. So you should actually have four dots here. Why do I know so much about ellipses you ask? I really wish I could tell you.
Quote:
|
"[b]I.../b]I don't want to die," I said, "I want to live!" The light around the three figures faded, and I could see three golden women with auras tinted red, blue and green smiling at me.
|
Space after the ellipsis. Paragraph break after the quote.
Quote:
|
"Then we shall honor your Courage, mortal." The red and blue figures approached me from behind, and held my arms.
|
Paragraph break after the quote.
Quote:
|
Whatever they were...they were insansely strong.
|
First off, if this were me, I would have put a comma, rather than an ellipsis after "were", but that's just a matter of personal taste. In any case, you need a space after the ellipsis. Also, "insanely" is spelled wrong. There's only one "s" in it.
Quote:
|
"We shall grant you our Chosen's power, o fledgling Aeon." Aeon? What the hell where they-
|
Paragraph break after the quote.
Quote:
|
Before I could think about anything else, she held up the ball of light in her left hand, and thrust it and her hand into my chest.
|
I actually don't think the comma after "hand" is necessary. Try reading it out loud yourself, but I don't really sense a pause there. Could be just me though.
Alrighty, that's it for the prologue. I'll be back to do the others some other time.
