Quote:
Originally Posted by Azerik "Cool" isn't enough to describe Evangelion...NGE is everything wrong with the world, everything right with the world, and everything in the word that needs to be shoved into people's faces. If everyone could understand this franchise as Hideaki Anno has tried to portray it to us, the world would be a better place. |
I disagree strongly.
Eva was an above-average show when it first aired, doing a decent job deconstructing the giant robot genre.
However, it's also deeply flawed from a whole bunch of things:
The symbolism is incredibly shallow and meaningless.
The plot is needlessly convoluted (I can sum most of it up in a few sentences, but it takes at least two watchings of the show and EoE to piece it all together).
The characters are universally unlikable. This is, apparently, by design. But that doesn't make it any more watchable.
When the characters weren't being impossible to like they were doing things that make no sense for their personalities. They also all tended to break off into random, meaningless, quotation-filled soliloquies.
The animation seriously dropped in quality and the show was plagued with all sorts of pacing problems. This is not entirely the studio's fault, but the finished product still suffers from them.
It had pointless diversions into fanservice as often as they could get away with it.
I'm glad I watched it, but it's also far over-hyped.
RahXephon, for example, takes almost all of the same themes and does a much better job with them. It starts out rather rocky, alas, but then finds its footing and tells the story Eva wanted to, only properly (ooh, burn,

). It does characterization properly, it actually tells you what the hell is going on, it has better animation and music, it has better pacing, and it makes sense.
Heck, even Gurren Lagann tells a similar story but does a much better job of it, simply by replacing all of the characters with ones who people can relate to and like.
So yeah, not a bad series, but hardly the amazing pinnacle of the art form that it was once hailed as.