Mario Vs Sonic--VOTING

[Umi]

Sorry for the wait. One rule, don't vote for your own team. I've also decided that because there can only be 10 poll options, people will vote based on the team, not the individual.

Sonic:

Umi-


Panique-


ursername180-


Lady Knives-


lugeasilver-


Moop-


Ed-


Prince Deity:

[Umi]

Mario:

Yamari-


Wind Waker13-


Tacheon Black-


exdid-


Nayru Blue-


Ice_Dragon-


HylianShroom-


Sora-

[Tacheon Black]

I must admit, Team Mario got their ass handed to them on this one...

If I could vote for Team Mario, however...

[Ender]

Sonic:

Umi- 8/10
Pani- 7/10
ursername180- 6.5/10
LK- 6.5/10
lugeasilver- 4/10
Moop- 8.7/10
Ed- 9.6/10 (****ing amazing)
Price Deity- 4/10

Mario:

Yamari- 7/10
Wind Waker13- 6.7/10
Tacheon Black- 5/10
exdid- 5.5/10
Nayru Blue- 9/10
Ice_Dragon- 7/10
HylianShroom- 8/10
Sora- 9/10

I'm going to go with Sonic, just because Ed's sig was so awesome.

[Teh Jocko]

I vote for team Mario.
All of the Sonic sigs look alike, especially Umi and Panique's... and I've sigs similar to Ed's...
I think that team Mario has more overall originality.

[Panique]

Originally Posted by Teh Jocko

All of the Sonic sigs look alike, especially Umi and Panique's

Just a question, how do they look alike apart from using the same render? xD (which I might say, I used first >.o)

[Ranil]

Twi, I don't think it's fair to vote for a team just because of one sig. I'm not saying this because I'm on team Mario, I'm saying all the sigs count, not just one. Anyway, because I participated and because I can't see all of the sigs, I won't vote. But I will say that the Sonic sigs I can see don't look all that much better than the Mario sigs I can see. :/

[spruce58052]

I especially like Tacheon Black's.

[Jason]

I know I have no part in this, but I decided to have a look... and Nayru Blue's Yoshi image is really the only worthy contender here. It goes beyond a simple signature and becomes a platform to show off who Yoshi is. It followed through with a good theme rather than a bunch of filters strung together. There's something called "art" and another thing called "creativity." Everything but the Yoshi signature here lacks the creativity part. I don't want to get into a "what is art" debate.

So, uh, yeah. Just wanted to say that. This thing should be no contest to Nayru Blue (and subsequently the Mario team, although I'm a die hard Sonic fan).


And yes, if he didn't warp the edges and make them 3D the signature wouldn't be nearly as amazing. It's those small things that make ALL the difference... I mean, spot ONE signature that stands out among all of these, and it's Nayru Blue's for the border and the stylistic design. Hello, winner.

[spruce58052]

^ I mostly agree with you. I like Nayru Blue's second to Tacheon Black's.

[Bacon Man]

Hmmm... It was a tough choice, but I liked Ed's ALOT.

[Umi]

I think my favorite on Mario is Sora's sig, with Nayru's as an incredibly close second.

[Tacheon Black]

Originally Posted by spruce58052

^ I mostly agree with you. I like Nayru Blue's second to Tacheon Black's.

Thank you much, but I actually thought I did a less-than-mediocre job...

[Prince Deity]

You spelled my name wrong. :mad:

also, If I can, I would like to change my entry to this:

[Zien]

Ill got with Team Mario

[Umi]

Originally Posted by Prince Deity

You spelled my name wrong. :mad:

also, If I can, I would like to change my entry to this:

I'm afraid I can't change your enrty, though the new one is very nice. 'Positive' is spelled wrong though. as for your name, fixed.

[Prince Deity]

Originally Posted by Umi

I'm afraid I can't change your enrty, though the new one is very nice. 'Positive' is spelled wrong though. as for your name, fixed.

no I didn't, look again...

[Ender]

Well, the only great sigs on Team Mario were Sora's and Nayru's. =\ Overall I thought Team Sonic had higher quality sigs.

[Cala]

I voted for Team Sonic. Team Mario has a couple good sigs, but Sonic has more.

[sugarpoultry]

Even tie! (since I voted.) well, I honestly love them all I voted for team sonic though. Some stuff in there is fabulous.

[sparkkirby]

I voted Team Sonic. Team Sonic had the most of the best signatures in my opinion, so they placed higher than Team Mario in my decision.

[Teh Jocko]

Originally Posted by Panique

Just a question, how do they look alike apart from using the same render? xD (which I might say, I used first >.o)

Hmm? I'm just saying that it looks both of the Sonics have similar lighting, and color... oh, and one is slightly "blurrier" than the other

Originally Posted by Twilight

Well, the only great sigs on Team Mario were Sora's and Nayru's. =\ Overall I thought Team Sonic had higher quality sigs.

According to your 'ratings', you gave the sonic team 54.3/80 points (a 6.7 average), and team Mario 57.2/80 points (a 7.15 average)...so it looks like you liked Mario's more

[Hooch]

I definetely loved Nayru Blue's the best, if my username were Yoshi I'd probably ask if I could have it right now. But the Sonic team had a lot of good sigs so I have to vote for them.