My new Zelda Game

Nintendo would never ever make this game, I'm sorry. It's just... No. They're already making ZWii which, no doubt, will have an even better story than this.

Even if Nintendo did find this petition -- oh my lord -- 1,000 people won't make them make it. You'd need, like, the whole fanbase and more to persuade them to make it, and even that has a low chance at working.

Originally Posted by poweroftwili

Sorry i meant that as in they wouldn't refuse it because it would sell.

Obviously it would sell, it has the name "The Legend of Zelda" in it. Anything with Zelda in it will sell.
Nintendo WILL refuse it, because they're already hard at work at the upcoming Zelda game. Just leave it to the Zelda team to come up with game ideas, alright? They come up with the best ones, a fan doesn't. I'm not telling you to stop thinking of game ideas, go right ahead and continue. I'm just saying Nintendo will not accept this idea. Don't even try to get them to make it, it won't work.

I'm sorry if I sound rude, but it's the truth.

Originally Posted by Tess

Nintendo would never ever make this game, I'm sorry. It's just... No. They're already making ZWii which, no doubt, will have an even better story than this.

Even if Nintendo did find this petition -- oh my lord -- 1,000 people won't make them make it. You'd need, like, the whole fanbase and more to persuade them to make it, and even that has a low chance at working.



Obviously it would sell, it has the name "The Legend of Zelda" in it. Anything with Zelda in it will sell.
Nintendo WILL refuse it, because they're already hard at work at the upcoming Zelda game. Just leave it to the Zelda team to come up with game ideas, alright? They come up with the best ones, a fan doesn't. I'm not telling you to stop thinking of game ideas, go right ahead and continue. I'm just saying Nintendo will not accept this idea. Don't even try to get them to make it, it won't work.

I'm sorry if I sound rude, but it's the truth.

you are probably right but that would be approx. $60,000 gross profit if the people that signed my petition bought the game should it come out and if I found a connection to nintendo it could work. They could get a new game out after the new game comes out.

It will not work.

Nintendo will never read it. If for some strange reason they did, they wouldn't even consider it. Even if you got 100,000 votes for it, it still wouldn't get anywhere.

What you have is a vague idea of a sequel for the sake of a sequel which doesn't really introduce anything new to the series

First off, you don't have a game idea, you have a fanfiction.

Secondly, what is the point of doing everything that Twilight Princess did ALL OVER again in your story?

Third, I like the premise of going into the Twilight Realm, but that's about the only thing I liked.

Four, your petition isn't going to do **** unless Nintendo sees it.

Number five, even if you do get your petition signed, you need a ton more than 1000 signatures.

Sixth point, try to come up with something more whole and complete before saying it to us. A good idea would be to say "These are the dungeons: Dungeon 1, Dungeon 2, Dungeon 3, etc..." rather than saying "I have 13 dungeons, and they are going to be awesome!"

I heard there was a huuuge American petition against Tingle and Nintendo actually saw it and decided to make sure Tingle didn't return to the US. Which is annoying, but so so funny. xD

Originally Posted by Zeldablue777

I heard there was a huuuge American petition against Tingle and Nintendo actually saw it and decided to make sure Tingle didn't return to the US. Which is annoying, but so so funny. xD

Gee, why would anybody want to get rid of Tingle? *sarcasm

Originally Posted by STUFF2o

Gee, why would anybody want to get rid of Tingle? *sarcasm

Most likely because the West seems to have a sort of "macho mature" culture where everything has to have violence and cannot be lighthearted.

I personally like Tingle. I tried out his game and ended up getting pretty far into it as well (before having to lend it back)

...Yeah I wanted to play Tingle's game. However, I don't want to have to deal with him and his money-stealin' self.

Originally Posted by Aleitheo

It will not work.

Nintendo will never read it. If for some strange reason they did, they wouldn't even consider it. Even if you got 100,000 votes for it, it still wouldn't get anywhere.

What you have is a vague idea of a sequel for the sake of a sequel which doesn't really introduce anything new to the series

This isn't just a vauge idea i have worked out almost the whole game storyline and some side-quests.

Originally Posted by Aleitheo

Most likely because the West seems to have a sort of "macho mature" culture where everything has to have violence and cannot be lighthearted.

I personally like Tingle. I tried out his game and ended up getting pretty far into it as well (before having to lend it back)

Nah, I think it's probably because of how creepy he is, and how incredibly annoying he was in Wind Waker. I think he's hilarious, but he shouldn't be in the realistic Zelda games.

Originally Posted by STUFF2o

Nah, I think it's probably because of how creepy he is, and how incredibly annoying he was in Wind Waker. I think he's hilarious, but he shouldn't be in the realistic Zelda games.

Totally, we should keep it realistic with hands that live in toilets.

The Tingle think actually pisses me off, I've read that the game is really good.

Originally Posted by poweroftwili

This isn't just a vauge idea i have worked out almost the whole game storyline and some side-quests.

Yes but as it has been stated your game brings absolutely nothing NEW to Zelda.

I'll quote Yahtzee here, in saying that your game is basically "The expansion pack that disguises itself as a sequel."

Originally Posted by TheBattler

First off, you don't have a game idea, you have a fanfiction.

Secondly, what is the point of doing everything that Twilight Princess did ALL OVER again in your story?

Third, I like the premise of going into the Twilight Realm, but that's about the only thing I liked.

Four, your petition isn't going to do **** unless Nintendo sees it.

Number five, even if you do get your petition signed, you need a ton more than 1000 signatures.

Sixth point, try to come up with something more whole and complete before saying it to us. A good idea would be to say "These are the dungeons: Dungeon 1, Dungeon 2, Dungeon 3, etc..." rather than saying "I have 13 dungeons, and they are going to be awesome!"

1.How is this just fanfiction?
2.this isn't exactly the same it is going to have the new species and areas in the game that expand Hyrule to an even bigger world
3. Thankyou that is what is the best part of it all as well
4.I am still working on finding a better way to get this to nintendo than just sending it to one of their office locations
5.I realize this and I am going to edit that to make it more than that when it gets a little higher on signatures

Originally Posted by Mr Mander

Yes but as it has been stated your game brings absolutely nothing NEW to Zelda.

I'll quote Yahtzee here, in saying that your game is basically "The expansion pack that disguises itself as a sequel."

So what's wrong with an expansion pack i ask?

Nothing at all, when it's an expansion pack.

When a game just recycles the exact same gameplay and plot as it's predecessor and calls itself a sequel, that's the problem.

Originally Posted by Mr Mander

Nothing at all, when it's an expansion pack.

When a game just recycles the exact same gameplay and plot as it's predecessor and calls itself a sequel, that's the problem.

Its not exactly the same, its different in the fact that there is a new storyline, new dungeons, new gameplay features(such as weilding two items at once, and new hidden skills even for the wolf form),new sidequests, bringing back spells and there will be an extra ociarna(you do not have to get it it is a side-quest), and brand new items along with old ones.

Originally Posted by STUFF2o

Nah, I think it's probably because of how creepy he is, and how incredibly annoying he was in Wind Waker. I think he's hilarious, but he shouldn't be in the realistic Zelda games.

People think he is creepy because they are looking at him completely the wrong way

As for him being in a "realistic" Zelda game, they would obviously have to make his design different from how it was in MM

yeah they would have to revamp his look

I must say, rehashing a previous game without significant new ideas is a terrible idea. And I must repost what I quoted in the other fangame thread:

From Nintendo's Wii customer service page:

Article 6: Submissions

Please do not send us any creative or original materials such as ideas for toys, games, or other products, or any creative suggestions, ideas, notes, drawings, concepts, or other information through the Wii Network Service or otherwise. Any unsolicited submissions become our sole and exclusive property and may be used by us with no obligation of confidentiality, payment, or attribution.

I don't care if Nintendo just takes it but I do have a plan to keep that from happening to me.