A game review section?
View Single Post
) [ ]
10-15-2009, 03:28 PM
Join Date: Aug 2007
Re: A game review section?
Originally Posted by
I know it sounds weird to have no commenting, but it makes more sense. You would have a person post a review. Have 20 people say "yeah, he's right" or "no, that game sucked", or something to that effect. Then, you would have another person want to post a review of the same thing. Now, his review has to be either a) in the middle of this big thread where it probably won't get noticed, or b) in a whole new thread for the same thing.
While feedback and opinions on it would be nice, it would dirty it up so badly that the concept of this having it's own board, or even sub catagory is just not going to work.
Actually on the contrary-- allowing commentary on the reviews is probably the only reason this
have its own board. If you were to allow commentary, it probably wouldn't be great to have eight reviews on the same game in General Gaming, but if there was a sub-board for reviews, then it'd be more acceptable, since that's more about the reviews themselves.
But not having commentary is completely pointless-- like I said, we're not here to inform, we don't have followings of people that we're relaying news to.
General opinions on games can either go in threads for them, or the recommendations thread.
I'm self-banned on request.
>My post about it<
View Public Profile
Find all posts by GooeyKablooie