I still say they need to somehow include Daniel Day-Lewis somehow, even if I doubt he'd ever do it. He vanishes completely into every role he's ever taken, much the same way Gary Oldman does, and Heath Ledger did as the Joker.

Johnny Depp is hit-or-miss when it comes to that. Sometimes he is completely immersed in a role (Jack Sparrow, Ed Wood, Raoul Duke, Edward, Sam) and sometimes you spend the whole movie sitting there thinking, 'hey, look, Johnny Depp!' (Dean Corso, Ichabod Crane, Roux, Willy Wonka).