View Single Post
  #11   [ ]
Old 05-06-2008, 11:39 AM
Mr. Lexxi Aileron Mr. Lexxi Aileron is offline
Plantman extraordinaire
Send a message via AIM to Mr. Lexxi Aileron
Join Date: Apr 2004
Location: The ZeldaInformer corner of ZU
View Posts: 12,200
Re: FSA is not Post-Flood

Quote:
Originally Posted by mohammedali View Post
So KG who's looking out for Hyrule just happens to pop in for OoT, hides away for hundreds of years whilst Hyrule is flooded and then drained, and then returns at a time where things are spookily just as they were in OoT? OK...
Not necessarily.

Malon and Talon and Anju and the Postman, etc. etc. aren't immortal; they just appear throughout the series inexplicably.

Quote:
And the Gorons leave a flooded Death Mountain to become traders on the sea, only for Death Mountain to be renamed and taken over by the Rito tribe, then renamed *back* to Death Mountain and then home of the Gorons once again? Right...
The Gorons become traders, and live on Goron Island, which is most likely Death Mountain.

Quote:
The only time Zora's are ever mentioned in PH is by items that were dropped by them in the past (and that's ignoring how real the events of PH were). So no help there.
1) The evil Zoras are enemies in PH.
2) There are no OoT Zoras in FSA.
3) Just because PH takes place in "another world" doesn't mean it takes place in "another dimension" any more than the designation of the Great Sea as the "world above" in TWW means that the Sea is in a different world than Hyrule.

Quote:
Dodongos in LoZ has nothing to do with a link to WW.
How about a link to PH?

Quote:
Deku Scrubs being in other games *excluding* WW suggests that there's less of a link with WW and more of a link with other games.
Not really.

FSA suggests that the Deku Scrubs had disappeared and needed to be awakened.

Quote:
Now, none of the points you originally made above give any suggestion of why FSA would ever come after WW
None of the points you're making are relevant to game placement unless they line up with other facts, which you don't have.

Quote:
Personally, I'd put it after OoT Child, where Ganondorf didn't get to the SR. This would explain why KG is still around, why Ganondorf is still a normal man, and why most of the tribes etc are where they were in OoT.
But not why the Gerudo aren't renowned for being wicked under Ganondorf's leadership, why no one knows of his exploits (he was a renowned murderer in OoT), and why the benevolent Zoras have apparently lost their homeland to the evil Zoras.

Quote:
Even if we forget for a second that we never see or hear of Hyrule being brought back
*cough*TFPRR*cough*

Quote:
and we ignore the King of Red Lions saying that Hyrule is washed away forever
"Wash away this ancient land of Hyrule!"

Quote:
and that we turn a blind eye to the fact that the land after WW is not to be named Hyrule etc.
"It will not be Hyrule."

Not "you can't name it Hyrule."

Daphnes is remarking that none of their attempts to recreate Hyrule will match the splendour of the holy land of Hyrule.

Quote:
Even after ignoring all these point, the idea of a world so similar to OoT like FSA coming after WW is still proposterous.
  • Death Mountain magically spawned a second peak.
  • The Lost Woods are now in the northwest, and the forestlands to the southeast have been partially cut down and replaced with a village.
  • Lake Hylia is now at the source of the river instead of at the mouth.
  • Kakariko Village has vacated the gorge nestled against Death Mountain and moved nearby the northwestern forest.
  • None of the temples from OoT appear in any form in FSA.
  • Vaati is the villain at large, and believed to be the King of Darkness.
  • The regions of Hyrule are largely divided by water, almost as if each region was once its own island.

So, FSA is close to OoT?
__________________


I love my Moonlight, my beautiful fiancée and ZU wife, my darling Kassi <33

Advice for men: Real Men. Real Problems. Real Answers.
Reply With Quote