View Single Post
  #5   [ ]
Old 05-03-2008, 01:57 AM
Aralith Aralith is offline
I AM BATMAN
Send a message via AIM to Aralith Send a message via MSN to Aralith Send a message via Skype™ to Aralith
Wii Code: 5607 0142 1955 3647 SSBB Code: 1075 1088 2841 Phantom Hourglass Code: 1504 6049 2798 Mario Kart DS Code:  1203 9572 1542 Pokemon Diamond/Pearl Code:  4511 0528 3059
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: Locked in my own mind.
View Posts: 1,148
Re: My First Timeline Theory

Quote:
Originally Posted by Erimgard View Post
:[
A hat is a very poor reason for timeline placement in my mind.
Also, Gustaf is not the Hero of Men. Gametrailers made that up.
It appears I should have done just one more Google search, as you are correct. I found nothing to corroborate the Hero of Men statement. However, I am not convinced that a hat is a poor reason because of this:

Quote:
WW Link had to dress like OoT Link.
But what about after that? Why should other Links wear a hat?
I would imagine that if they felt the need to honor a hero that lived more than a hundred years ago and then that honor was corroborated by WW Link's deeds that the people of Hyrule would still want to honor him. Plus the fact that they still continue to wear that cap either proves that they are honoring that, or that just every Link in existence ever just decided that a cap was a good idea. Way too coincidental and chancy for me.

Quote:
Majora's Mask tells us that the Royal Family passed down his legends.
He was still renowned as a hero.
Fair enough. I concede that point to you. However, as I stated other reasons for my positioning of both MC and TP, I do not feel that this is a big blow to my theory.

Quote:
The Oracles cannot be on separate timelines.
Have some bitterlime copy pasta:
I see you are right. It has been far too long since I've played those games. Still, if I placed them both on the child timeline with no merge, and then have it lead straight into LA it wouldn't damage what I have right now all that much.


Quote:
If anything, the similar mirrors are proof of opposite timelines.
Why make two games with virtually the same scenario [Dark Mirror/tribe, Ganon spreading darkness, Ganon using a pawn to divert attention] on the same timeline?
Also, it's a very very big assumption to say that the Twilight Mirror was repaired or that there were more than one. I think TP makes it clear that the Twilight Mirror is done for after TP.
Oh, sure enough that Mirror is probably done for. But my point was that the ruler of the Twilight was the only one who could destroy the mirror. Since the Twilight people are descended from the Dark Interlopers and they've been passing down this magic for a while now, I'm pretty sure that the Interlopers had the same magic as the Twili. Thus, the ruler of the Dark Interlopers could have just as easily destroyed the Mirror of Twilight as Midna did. Which if their were only one, then why wouldn't he have just done that? Certainly would have saved his people a lot of suffering and despair. It is purely theory, but I feel that it is at least somewhat supported by in-game evidence. Even if only indirectly.


Quote:
The Twilight Mirror takes you into the Twilight Realm
The Magic Mirror takes you out of the Sacred Realm
I believe very highly that they are not the same mirror.
Actually, both mirrors take you both direction. Granted the Magic Mirror in ALttP can only create one portal at a time from the normal world, but it still takes you both directions, as does the Mirror of Twilight. In fact, the Mirror of Twilight can also only create one portal at a time from the normal world, so doesn't that kind of lend itself to the possibility that they are the same mirror, or at least that they have the same origins.

Quote:
And also, how do you explain the Seal that exist in aLttP, and what is the Imprisoning/Seal War spoken of in the game?
Well, it's a bit of a stretch, but at the end of FSA, Ganon was sealed with the Four Sword. Now, here's where the stretch comes in. This explains the idea of the Seal War, but it doesn't explain how Ganon got from the Four Sword to the Sacred Realm. However, I do have a theory on that one, I just completely forgot to leave it out of my initial post. I'm sure you could agree with me that the Four Sword shares some similar traits to the Master Sword. For example, you need it to banish evil. It was the only weapon that could have sealed Vaati in both FS games. It's possible that they both have same origins. After all, as far as I know there has been no definite origin story on the Master Sword. The only real thing we know about it is that it's a key to the Sacred Realm, which if the Four Sword is similar in origin to the Master Sword could just as well lead to the Sacred Realm, explaining both the Seal War, and the fact that Ganon is sealed in the Sacred Realm at the beginning of ALttP. I don't really expect it to convince you, as it is rather weak, but is is a possible explanation with at least some in-game evidence, although admittedly very little, to answer your question.
Reply With Quote