I find it kind of ironic that one of the recurring things people post under "dislikes" is the fact that it's similar to OoT. First of all, I fail to see how that could be a bad thing...and furthermore, people tend to overlook all of the things in TP that really set it apart from it's fellow big-zelda title brethren. I could go on about this, but I think I'll just stick to listing my likes and dislikes...

Likes
-Beautiful art direction
-The sheer size of the game
-Epic boss battles
-Nostalgia factor
-Hidden skills
-Midna
-Dungeons (though, like some of the other folks here, I can't say I enjoyed the Lakebed temple a great deal...)
-More cinematic flair than previous Zelda titles
-Link, while still morbidly mute, somehow seems to possess more personality in this game than any other
-Ability to transform into a wolf
-The eerie particle effects and distorted colors found in the twilight realm
-Interesting story (in my opinion)
-Great music (I loved the dramatic Hyrule field theme, the song that played when night fell, and many more...and let's not overlook the inclusion of many old classics. )

Dislikes
-About the aforementioned epic boss battles...while they were indeed epic, they were more often than not annoyingly easy. I'm not one of those gamers that demands a hardcore challenge, and while I find TP to be a perfect balance in overall difficulty and presentation (one that appeals to the casual crowd drawn in by the Wii, and yet still gives veteran Zelda players something to sink their teeth into), this is one aspect I think they could have worked on a little bit. Not a huge complaint, though.
-Collecting tears of light (I don't mind the first two as much as the third, in Lake Hylia...it's just annoying when they're spread apart like that...)
-While it wasn't a constant annoyance throughout, after hearing what Nintendo can pull off with Orchestrated Music in Super Mario Galaxy, I found the lack of orchestrated music in TP rather disheartening. Hopefully, the next Wii Zelda will include fully orchestrated music...
-Zelda "fans" who piss and moan about TP's relatively tame difficulty and about how the series is slowly growing "stale", even when TP stands as a testament to Nintendo's continued efforts to keep the Zelda series remarkable in all regards while introducing new content (was the inclusion of a variety of hidden skills, the ability to turn into a wolf which has the ability to utilize it's senses to find items and secrets, new items, old items redesigned to feel new again, new, immersive controls with the Wii version, and a plethora of side quests ranging from an in-depth fishing game, snowboarding against a yeti, and much more, not enough?)

Phew...that's all.