View Single Post
  #3   [ ]
Old 04-07-2008, 11:25 AM
GentleArtillery GentleArtillery is offline
Gone
Join Date: Jan 2008
View Posts: 734
Re: Animals: instincts, desires, emotions?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Hombre de Mundo View Post
Do animals have desires? Is it even possible to actually ask such a question? I mean... duh

I'd like to say something though. Plants can stretch their roots deeper down the ground in search for water. Let's say there's an underground body of water, a plant could dig the roots deep enough to access that water. Would that count as desire? Neh, plants have no brains, and wouldn't be able to have emotions. They're like machines. They do stuff, but they don't have the desire to. They're just programed to do it (through DNA). The same would go for jellyfish, I guess. They don't have hearts, brains or nerve systems... they just are.
Now, is what the animals have desires, or instinct? And, does it separate them enough from plants in order for us to non-arbitrarily care more for animals than for plants?
I believe so, but I'm too lazy to think up any "objective" reasons myself.
Reply With Quote