Very nice outcomes there, xXxMidnaxXx.
1st sig - This is my least favourite out of the 3, but I still reckon you are doing an
amazing job, for only being a beginner at photoshop. The render could be blended in a bit more, but overall it's a pretty good job. Though the text seems to take up a lot of the sig, and draw you away from the actual background and render itself, but that's no problem. I dislike the red border though, but that's fine, it doesn't matter what colour border you have really, it's just this one doesn't seem to go with the sig. It looks great though. Nice job man.
2nd sig - This is probaly my favourite aswell. It's hard to choose though, I really like this one and the 3rd one a lot. With this one everything is really well blended, and the flow is perfect. I can't seem to see any flaws with this one, it's a nice job. I'm sure you're going to improve in no time, especially with how fast you learn things. Well done.
3rd sig - This is a great job aswell. The render is a bit choppy, but that's ok. I'll make you a tutorial on the tools, so you know how to use them all, just incase you don't know what a few do, soon. So then your renders shouldn't be choppy when you cut them out, well unless that one was already bad quality in the first place. Anyways, I like how it's dark around the bottom, then light at the top with different kind of effects. Looks nice. Great job.
Overall you did a
fantastic job, you really did. I'm happy you had done more than just one sig aswell, thanks for that. And by looking at them, you followed the tutorial pretty well. You also did well with the text on all of them, except they look a little blurred, but that's fine, it's probaly because that font isn't really ment for that size. Well I don't think so.. But anyways, really great job man, you should be proud, I know I am

.
I'll try and get the tutorial for tools ready for the both of you tomorrow or the day after. Oh and yous won't have to wait for ages like last time, I promise I'll get it done as soon as I can. Thank you for doing the tutorial.
Oh and Twilight |_ ink, just reminding you about the assignment on the tutorial, can you please get it done by no later than tuesday. Thank you.