I think it's because it only keeps records based on where you fish, so if you fish in the fishing hole, they only record your biggest catch caught there, otherwise, i think the others are available in your menu screen, but im not sure

__________________
Sheikahchica is my amazing ZU girlfriend <3 | Thank you to Blackfeather for the beautiful sig. And Karma for the adorable avy.

DK : "I thought you were taller than that. It's going to be much easier to wrestle you to the ground in a completely homosexual way when I see you."